INGROUND POOL Comparison

Which Type of Inground Pool Is Best for Your Backyard?

Choosing the right type of pool is one of the biggest decisions you’ll make when transforming your backyard. Whether you’re comparing gunite, fiberglass, or vinyl liner pools, the goal is the same: create a beautiful, lasting space for relaxation, fun, and making memories. But not all pools are created equal.

At Custom Pool Pros, we believe an informed customer is a confident customer—and that’s why we build gunite pools: the most customizable, long-lasting option on the market today.

Gunite vs. Fiberglass vs. Vinyl: What You Need to Know

FeatureGunite PoolFiberglass PoolVinyl Liner Pool
Lifespan50+ years15–25 years7–12 years
CustomizationUnlimited shapes, depths, and featuresLimited to pre-molded shellsBasic rectangular or oval shapes
DurabilityHigh – built from steel-reinforced concreteModerate – prone to cracking or warping over timeLow – liners can rip, bubble, or fade
AestheticsLuxury look with custom finishesLimited design optionsBudget appearance
Cost Over TimeMinimal maintenance, no liner or shell replacementHigh if shell needs replacement or repairRecurring cost to replace liners every 7–10 years

Why Choose a Gunite Pool?

Built to Last a Lifetime

Gunite pools are made with steel-reinforced concrete and finished with high-end plaster or pebble surfaces. Unlike fiberglass or vinyl, there’s no risk of bubbling, cracking, or liner tears. Your investment will stand the test of time.

More Customization, Same Timeline

You might be surprised to learn that a gunite pool can be built in a similar timeframe as a fiberglass pool—and at a comparable price. But unlike fiberglass, you’re not locked into a cookie-cutter shape. From infinity edges to sun shelves to built-in spas, gunite gives you true design freedom.

Worry-Free Ownership

Fiberglass shells can develop spider cracks or separate from the ground. Vinyl liners can tear or leak. Gunite? It’s solid, reliable, and low-maintenance—saving you thousands in long-term repairs and replacements.

Gunite/Concrete vs. Vinyl vs. Fiberglass Pools

Gunite/ Concrete
Vinyl Liner
Fiberglass
Speed of
Installation
💪💪💪
💪💪
💪💪
Durability
💪💪💪
💪
💪
Longevity
💪💪💪
💪💪
💪
Customization
of shapes/ sizes
💪💪💪
💪💪
💪
Price
💪💪💪
💪💪
💪💪💪
Hassle-Free
Maintenance
💪💪💪
💪💪💪
💪💪💪
Renovation-Ability
💪💪💪
💪💪
💪
Finished Look
💪💪💪
💪
💪
Access
💪💪💪
💪💪
💪

The Truth About Fiberglass and Vinyl

  • Fiberglass shells can warp with shifting soil, especially in freeze-thaw climates.

  • Vinyl liners need to be replaced every 7–10 years—and are prone to punctures, fading, and algae buildup behind the liner.

  • Resale value suffers with non-gunite pools, which are often seen as temporary or lower-end solutions.

Gunite/Concrete Pools

💪

💪

💪

Concrete-Pool-Structure.jpg
Gunite/Concrete Pools

💪 💪 💪

Vinyl Pools

💪

💪

Vinyl-Pool-1.jpg
Vinyl Pools

💪 💪

Fiberglass Pools

💪

fiberglass-pool-building-in-nj.jpg
Fiberglass Pools

💪

Custom Pool Pros: Built for Beauty, Built to Last

We specialize in building custom gunite pools that elevate your outdoor living space and increase your home’s value. With decades of experience, financing options, and a team dedicated to your vision, we make the process smooth from design to your first swim.

Still Deciding? Let’s Talk.

If you’re comparing pool types, we’ll walk you through real costs, timelines, and design options—no pressure, just facts.

📞 Call us at (717) 214-1900 or
📅 Schedule a Free Design Consultation

Choose a pool that lasts a lifetime. Choose gunite.